So for this one I had a little help from my friends. First I needed a great recipe. That’s where my neighbor, who just happens to be a professional baker stepped in. Meet Amy Schneider of Amy’s.
She makes cakes, cookies, cupcakes and more sweet treats exclusive and made-to-order for everyone’s simchas and celebrations in these parts. Mike and Ikes are her favorite candy, maybe that’s what we get along so well. Her favorite flavor is blue, mine is red – so maybe that’s really why we get along so well. I asked her to “make something sweet, something special and something easy with Mike and Ikes”. She happily obliged.
Next came my friend from FuninJerusalem.com Joanna Shebson. I said “I know your husband is in real estate and probably has a bunch of gorgeous kitchens he can secure for me to use as our set… but… what I really want… is to use yours. So do you mind if we come in with a crew of 7 and take over your house for 10 hours?” Thankfully she obliged. Maybe that’s why we also get along so well.
So this here is the fabulous finished product. Finally we reveal our top secret recipe for Amy’s Mike and Ike Bejeweled Sugar Cookies – they are perfect and pretty and now all yours.
Scroll to continue
More Love
Family Heirloom Cholent
This cholent recipe used to be my hubby’s secret, but I finally got it out of him and now …
Deli Roll
I never heard of deli rolls until I hit the kosher Shabbos scene. It was apparent that …
Get the recipe in detail here, Mike and Ike Bejeweled Sugar Cookies.
Disclaimer: This post and video are part of a partnership with Mike and Ike, all opinions are my own.
Looks good. I will have to try it.
love the red ones
lots of fun!!!
Had I some mike & ike I would bake these tonight!
My favorite Mike and Ike colour is yellow:) YUMMY!
The green ones!!
I’m a green fan, but my husband is the real Mike and Ike fan. He literally will buy 4 or 5 boxes at a time.
Whatever Amy makes is sure to be delish! (In any color;)
What a fun idea to bake with mike and Ike
Mine’s strawberry 🙂
Amy Schneider makes the BEST BAKED GOODS!
RED is my favorite color Mike and Ike.I love your newsletters and watching your cooking demo videos. Thank you.
I like the red ones!!
Yellow is my favorite.
mine is red
Great Recipe and so easy!!
forgot to add that we like the berry flavored M&I’s
i can’t wait ti try these yummy-sounding cookies on the grandchildren…and their parents
I like lemon
Definately green. 🙂
Definitely red! But I found the lemonade mix this summer that was a new twist.
I like the green Mike & Ikes.
Green
What fun! Thanks!
I love the red ones!
I will add this recipe to my collection
Cherry.
Love the red mike and ikes.
I’m a huge mike n Ike fan! Can’t wait to try these!
Yum!!
Red of course!
Mine fell apart last night…these worked beautifully…will always use this recipe…
My favorite color is the original red Mike and Ike, however, I love pairing it with the yellow ones too!!
Red is super! When you are hungry for a treat…they all taste good!
That’s an easy pick – yellow! I love lemon
I would love to try those sugar cookies.
These look so easy to make. I know my nieces would love these. Yum!
green!
I like the red ones.
I wish I could say all the colors! I love Mike & Ikes! I always purchased them when I went to the movies. The green ones are probably my all-time favorites.
I love red cherry!
I like the green ones
cherry!
My favorite is the red. Thanks so much.
Green Mike & Ikes are my favorite!
I love these cookies
I love the cherry flavor 🙂
red!
the blue kinds are my favorite
These look so fun and delicious! The kids will love!